AI Ad Creative Software
Pencil
SF 8.1Enterprise GenAI ad creative orchestration platform
Contact sales
AI Ad Creative Software
Arcads
SF 7.8AI UGC video ad generator tool
From $110/moPaid plans start at $110 per month
Quick decision guide
Choose based on your workflow
Pencil may fit better if...
- Pencil Pro
- Multi Model
- Brand Controls
Arcads may fit better if...
- AI UGC Avatars
- Script To Video
- Voice Synthesis
Overview
How each tool is described
Pencil
What is Pencil?
Pencil is an AI creative and advertising platform for brands, agencies, and marketing teams. It combines configurable AI agents, multiple text/image/video models, brand knowledge, browser-based editing, repeatable creative workflows, bulk variations, ad-account integrations, and performance analysis in one production environment.
- Agent-based creation: Pencil’s agents are configured around four components—instructions, knowledge, capabilities, and an underlying AI model. Prebuilt and custom agents can handle tasks such as audience research, campaign strategy, copywriting, image and video generation, ad creation, scripting, and creative-performance analysis. Agents can access Brand Libraries, uploaded files, web search, research tools, and other integrations, and multiple agents can be chained through the same workflow.
- Creative production at scale: teams can generate text, images, and video, then refine text, imagery, video, and HTML/display creatives in Pencil’s browser editor. Workflows connect models, agents, prompts, files, scoring, and approval steps into repeatable production sequences, while Sheets and Feed Variations can generate localized or personalized creative across products, audiences, languages, regions, and markets.
- Performance and publishing loop: connected media accounts can import creatives and performance metrics into Pencil’s Results and Insights dashboards and export finished ads back to supported platforms. The Creative Insights agent analyzes creative-level performance and turns patterns into recommendations for future work. Pencil also offers creative scoring, but its current Media Performance Score specifically predicts relative CTR performance using sufficient historical data from a connected Meta account; other connected platforms do not currently feed that particular score.
- Commercial considerations: Core costs $14/month with 50 generations and one workspace; Growth costs $55/month with 250 generations and unlimited workspaces; annual rates are currently $11 and $44 per month respectively. Pro uses custom pricing with unlimited generations, bulk feed-based production, unlimited users, brands and markets, access controls, AI-governance provisions, dedicated customer success, and enterprise consumption pricing across models and modalities. Pencil updated generation accounting in August 2026 so usage is increasingly tied to the actual model and workload rather than a uniform generation cost.
Pencil is most relevant to advertising teams that want AI ideation and generation connected directly with brand governance, high-volume creative adaptation, approval, media activation, and performance-informed iteration rather than using separate tools for each stage.
Arcads
What is Arcads?
Arcads is an AI advertising creative platform for performance marketers that generates video ads using a library of 1,000+ AI actors, custom AI avatars, product visuals, text-to-speech, and multiple AI video models. Its current workspace combines generation, editing, presets, and collaborative creative workflows for producing ad variations at scale.
- Creative role: marketers can turn scripts and product concepts into UGC-style ads, talking-avatar videos, product showcases, app demonstrations, and other performance-ad formats without arranging repeated creator shoots. Users can select an existing AI actor or create custom avatars that can hold products, display apps, or wear supplied items.
- Production workflow: Arcads supports model selection, ready-made ad presets, translation, subtitles, video extension, upscaling, remixing, text-to-speech, and prompt-based emotion control. Localization supports more than 30 languages, while Create Workflow provides a shared canvas for building repeatable creative-production processes.
- Implementation checks: buyers should assess expected generation volume, actor and avatar requirements, localization needs, team workflows, brand-review processes, and API requirements. Arcads focuses primarily on creative production; campaign publishing, store research, and performance analysis require the relevant external advertising or business tools and connectors.
- Commercial considerations: Arcads is sold through Standard and Customized subscription offers, with each subscription providing a defined credit allowance used for video and other generations. Credit consumption can vary by generation type or model. API access is restricted to Customized offers, while customized plans can also support additional credit usage beyond the contracted allowance.
Arcads is particularly relevant to performance marketing teams and agencies that need to produce, localize, and test large volumes of video ad creative without depending on repeated filming, editing, and creator coordination.
Side-by-side
Key differences
Criteria
AI Ad Creative SoftwarePencil
AI Ad Creative SoftwareArcads
Best for
AI Ad Creative Software
AI Ad Creative Software
Score
8.1/10
7.8/10
Pricing
Contact sales
From $110/mo
Category / audience
AI Marketing & Content Software › AI Ad Creative Software
- pencil pro
- brandtech
- enterprise genai
AI Marketing & Content Software › AI Ad Creative Software
- ai video ads
- ai ugc
- avatar ads
Feature check
Side-by-side feature check
Feature
Pencil
Arcads
Pencil ProEnterprise GenAI orchestration product for brands
-
Multi ModelIntegrates OpenAI, Stable Diffusion, Runway models
-
Brand ControlsBrand guideline enforcement on every output
-
Media IntegrationsDirect integrations with Meta, TikTok, YouTube
-
Performance PredictionPredict ad performance before going live
-
Enterprise SecurityData isolation and enterprise security controls
-
12 capabilities compared.12 differentiating rows are shown first.
Use cases
Who they're built for
Pencil
- Generate enterprise GenAI ad creativesGenerate enterprise GenAI ad creative across multiple integrated foundation models
- Apply brand controls at scaleApply brand guideline enforcement on every generated creative output
- Publish ads to Meta TikTokPublish generated ads directly to Meta, TikTok, and YouTube
Arcads
- Generate AI UGC style videosGenerate AI UGC style videos with avatar creator delivery
- Use AI avatar creator libraryUse library of AI avatar creators for ad delivery
- Run DTC paid social adsRun DTC paid social ads with AI UGC style content
The trade-offs
Pros & cons of each tool
Trade-offs
Pencil
Pros
- Enterprise GenAI orchestration across multiple foundation AI models
- Strong brand controls and direct media channel publishing
- Backed by Brandtech Group with enterprise creative resources
Cons
- Enterprise positioning with quote based pricing for buyers
- Smaller advertisers may find platform overpowered for needs
- Brandtech ownership concentrates platform direction inside one group
Trade-offs
Arcads
Pros
- Generates AI UGC style videos with avatar creators
- Multi language output for international ad video campaigns
- Cuts cost of UGC creator booking and filming
Cons
- AI avatar UGC quality varies by script and target
- Brands committed to authentic real creator content may pass
- Pricing higher than entry AI video ad tools today
Final verdict
Best fit depends on your workflow
Current catalog data shows meaningful overlap between Pencil and Arcads. Use the signals below to decide based on workflow, ecosystem, pricing, and implementation fit.
Differentiators available
Pencil has 4 visible decision signals and Arcads has 4.
Score signal
Pencil has the higher SoftFinders Score in the current catalog data.
Choose Pencil if…
- Generate enterprise GenAI ad creatives
- Apply brand controls at scale
- Publish ads to Meta TikTok
- Pencil Pro
Choose Arcads if…
- Generate AI UGC style videos
- Use AI avatar creator library
- Run DTC paid social ads
- AI UGC Avatars
TRY THEM YOURSELF
See which one fits your workflow
Both tools have their strengths, the best way to decide is to spend a few minutes inside each.